J.P.Sommerville

 

Sir Robert Cecil, 1st Earl of Salisbury (1563-1612)

The age of Salisbury.

 

1. James I

James I met no real opposition when he succeeded to the throne of England. The only serious rival claim was that of Arabella Stuart, who had no supporters. (in 1610, she married Sir William Seymour, the Grey/Suffolk claimant, and this posed enough of a threat to James for him to imprison them both. Arabella died in prison (1615), but William was released and became a loyal supporter of Charles I in the Civil War).
England's Roman Catholics hoped that James would treat them better than Elizabeth had done, since they had supported his mother, Mary Queen of Scots.
 

 Dunfermline Palace
One of James VI's main Scottish residences

On his accession, James made a leisurely journey south, handing out knighthoods as he went. Many nobility and gentry looked askance at James being equally generous to his Scots' supporters, who were rewarded lavishly from English assets. However, James was pleased to leave Scotland, and only returned for one visit. He had Scots' favorites but few of them were elevated to positions of real power in England.
James was an intellectual - a true scholar who wrote poetry, political theory (maintaining the rights of kings) and theology (against the radical Dutch Protestant Conrad Vorstius). He easily grew bored of routine administration and devoted far more time to hunting and drinking with his favorites.
 

"On Saturday last the King killed a buck in Eltham Park and so soon as it was opened stood in the belly of it and bathed his bare feet and legs with the warm blood; since which time he has been so nimble that he thinketh this the only remedy for the gout."
(1619)
       

 

2. The Catholic threat - the Gunpowder Plot and the Oath of Allegiance

Henry Garnet (1555-1606)

 

James soon faced Roman Catholic conspiracy. Robert Catesby, Thomas Percy, and Guy Fawkes led some Catholic gentlemen in the Gunpowder Plot to blow up the king and his two sons on the day that Parliament opened. (They intended to capture James I' daughter, Princess Elizabeth (1596-1662) and rule through her).
One of the conspirators warned his relative, Lord Monteagle not to attend the opening of Parliament, he took the letter to the government and the whole plot unraveled. On 5 November 1605, Guy Fawkes was arrested amongst his barrels of gunpowder in a cellar beneath the Houses of Parliament. (Bonfire Night has been celebrated in England ever since with fireworks and the burning of a "guy" - the stuffed replica of Guy Fawkes.) Under torture, he confessed and gave the names of his fellow conspirators.
The conspirators fled but were pursued and those who were not killed were captured and executed.
The involvement of the Jesuit priest, Henry Garnet, who confessed to knowing of the plot in advance increased anti-Catholic feeling.
In the wake of the Plot, Parliament passed new legislation against English Catholics, including a requirement that they should take an Oath of Allegiance repudiating all intentions of overthrowing James.
After 1605, the Catholic threat diminished, especially as internal squabbles between the Jesuits and the secular priests continued.

 


One of James I's (anonymous) tracts defending the Oath of Allegiance
[The title page states "1607" because it was published in February:  until 1752 the New Year began 25 March, not 1 January]
[More on changes in the early-modern calendar]

The Oath of Allegiance sparked a lengthy controversy between Catholic and Protestant theologians and political theorists, to which James I himself contributed. The three books he authored (in 1608, 1609, and 1615) confirm the views that James expressed in his speeches to Parliament that kings receive power from God alone - not from their people - and are accountable only to Him.


 
 

 

3. The Hampton Court Conference and puritanism

"… now we, to the number of more than a thousand of your Majesty's subjects and ministers, all groaning as under a common burden of Human rites and ceremonies, do with one joint consent, humble ourselves at your Majesty's feet, to be eased and relieved in this behalf".

From the Millenary Petition (1603).

 

As James rode to London in 1603, he was presented with a Millenary Petition (so-called because it claimed more than a thousand petitioners) asking for various puritan reforms of the English Church (abolition of the use of the sign of the cross in baptism, of the ring in marriage, of the surplice and so on).
In response, James appointed a conference between puritan representatives and the bishops with himself as arbiter. It met from 14 - 18 January 1604, and James took the Bishops' side. He spent far more time talking with them, threw a tantrum when the puritans' leader John Reynolds mentioned 'presbytery', and ended the Conference with no concessions except some minor changes of wording in the Book of Common Prayer.
In 1604, Convocation passed canons (church regulations) that specifically enforced and defended the very practices puritans disliked (such as bowing the head at the name of Jesus and the use of the sign of the cross in baptism). About 90 puritans who would not conform were deprived of their livings. Puritans complained about this, particularly to Parliament whose consent to canons many thought necessary, but was not obtained.

 
Under the mild rule of George Abbot (1562-1633), Archbishop of Canterbury from 1611, little attempt was made to harass puritans, and the conflict in the Church of England remained muted.

 

A few puritan extremists founded small sects outside the Church of England. The "semi-Separatists" or "Independents" were established by Henry Jacob; and the General Baptists by John Smith the se-baptist. Although tiny in number, these congregations were important because of their part in settling New England from 1620.

 

4. Salisbury and finance

Thomas Sackville, Earl of Dorset (1535-1608)

 

Under Thomas Sackville, Earl of Dorset, (James' first Lord Treasurer) royal revenues increased.  Peace with Spain led to more trade and higher customs revenues. Unfortunately, James' expenditure increased still more quickly and by 1608 the royal debt stood at £600,000.
Salisbury was forced to sell crown land to defray the debt. He also tried to introduce new sources of revenue - in particular, impositions.

 


An imposition on the dried zante grape or "currant" provoked Bate's case

The Tudor monarchs had used impositions occasionally as a means of regulating trade, but after Bate's Case (1606), they were collected on a wide range of goods, bringing in c. £ 60,000 each year.

Impositions angered Members of Parliament who saw them as taxation without consent. Their anger made James less willing to call Parliament, believing they would not grant him direct taxation.
An attempt was made to resolve the conflict with the Great Contract proposal of 1610. In exchange for a guaranteed income of £200,000 per annum from a land tax, James would give up impositions, purveyance and wardship as sources of revenue. The negotiations collapsed in an atmosphere of mutual mistrust, and reluctance by both sides to make concessions.

 


A session of the Court of Wards

5. Parliament

The first Parliament of James I

(i)

19 March -16 July 1604

(ii)

5 November 1605 - 27 May 1606

(iii)

18 November 1606 - 4 July 1607

(iv)

9 February - 23 July 1610

(v)

16 October - 6 December 1610

 

Only one Parliament met while Salisbury was chief minister, but it had several sessions.
 

The 1604 session saw a dispute between King and Parliament over the question of who should decide in the case of a disputed election. Two gentlemen Goodwin and Fortescue both claimed that they had been elected as knight for the shire of Buckinghamshire. The king said that the Court of Chancery should decide the case; the House of Commons said that it should decide. The House of Commons won, and established the right to decide its own membership.
A few members angered by James' intervention drew up an Apology asserting parliamentary rights against the crown, but it was never officially adopted by the House of Commons.
1605-6: united in reaction to the Gunpowder Plot, king and parliament cooperated smoothly in drawing up anti-Catholic legislation.

 


Map of Westminster palace
where Parliament met


1607: James hoped that this parliament would enact the Union of England and Scotland, but the Commons resisted his proposals for free trade and reciprocal citizenship. They thought that this would benefit only poor Scotsmen, who would take English jobs.
James obtained part of what he wanted through the courts. The judges in Calvin's Case (1608)  ruled that all Scotsmen born since James' accession in 1603 were naturalized Englishmen and vice versa. (Some Members of Parliament believed that this ruling infringed parliamentary rights).
1610: This session saw bitter debates over impositions, the Commons' insistence on its right to free debate of all questions, and the failure of the Great Contract.

 


Robert Cecil's tomb

 

                   

Previous lecture

Next lecture

Return to top of page Course schedule Home